I recently posted a photo on my instagram story depicting a local bar’s awesome selection of bitters, with the caption: “Sober date tip: if the bar has a beautiful collection of bitters, order a bitters and soda!” I fancied myself quite clever and adultlike with my club soda and chamomile and citrus infused bitters, but I was met with messages that ranged from a frantic “bitters have alcohol!” to an inquisitive “bitters have alcohol?” I knew that bitters do, in fact, contain alcohol, but I also knew that this amount was so negligible that I was likely to be exposed to more alcohol by drinking that mango juice that was 3 days past its expiration. However, I realized that this is not common knowledge and is in fact a pretty controversial topic in Soberland. So I decided to do a little “real” research of my own…
What are bitters? Bitters are fun little elixirs that are – yes – alcohol-based. They can be used to aid in digestion or to add complexity to cocktails (and mocktails). Seeds, spices, fruits, tree bark, roots are infused into a neutral alcohol base, creating a highly concentrated, very flavorful concoction that is then sold in small bottles. Small bottles – because they are meant to be consumed in extremely, almost ridiculously small quantities, such as a dash per drink (maybe 2).
Bitters alcohol content. Varies, but typically around 45% alcohol for classics (like Angostura). This is comparable to vanilla extract (35%) or, say, Captain Morgan. However, like vanilla. It’s a flavoring, meant to be used in very small amounts. In fact, vanilla extract is legally mandated to be atleast 35% alcohol per the FDA – anything less is labelled as imitation. So why don’t you need an ID to buy vanilla? The trick here (as with bitters), is these substances are considered “non-potable,” as in a reasonable human would not be able to tolerate/drink them in a large enough volume to actually reap the effects of their alcohol content – think mouthwash or perfume (for a fascinating history of vanilla, its high alcohol content and prohibition, check out this article). As this article puts it, “if you ever did try to drink non-potable bitters like Angostura, your tastes buds just might go on strike for a week or two.”
Alcohol content in soda + bitters. So now we know that bitters is super high in alcohol but that we are using it in tiny, tiny amounts – just a dash’ll do ya. Then how much alcohol is actually in a soda + bitters? OK so, let’s assume you use ½ tsp (or .1 oz) of 45% ABV bitters – and I am being generous here, this would be a pretty bitter-heavy drink (a quick experiment with my Cordial Organics “Celebrate” CBD Bitters showed me that their recommended dose of “1 full dropper” was just about ¼ tsp).
.45 (ABV) x 0.1 oz bitters = .036 total alcohol content
Total drink volume: 12.0 oz (soda or tonic) + 0.5 oz (melted ice) + 0.1 oz (bitters) = 12.6 ounce drink
.036% alcohol content / 12.6 oz drink = .00285% ABV
So your standard bitters + soda drink = .003% ABV. And maybe you’ve notice I rounded up, because again – I am very generous.
(Here is how I did this math: https://www.thespruceeats.com/determining-cocktail-alcohol-proof-76030)
How does the alcohol content of bitters + soda measure up to other foods? This .003% is still less alcohol than is found in most common foods, like breads and ripe fruit (not even kidding, guys). In a study in the Journal of Analytical Toxicity (yasss), the researchers examined the amount of ethanol content in several common foods in order to determine the average amount of alcohol that a 6 year old child could be exposed (it’s always for the children). In this study, it was shown that grape juice contains up to .086% alcohol, while a very ripe banana can have up to .004% and “American style burger rolls” contain a whopping .128%. And just for funsies: Some vinegar has .264%. Kefir? .002%. So essentially, the alcohol content of your bitters drink falls somewhere between kefir and a very ripe banana.
What about kombucha? Throwing this in here because it seems to go hand-in-hand with bitters in these types of debates. Alcohol is naturally present in kombucha due to the fermentation process, albeit in slightly higher numbers than the study above. It is also a bit harder to pin down as each brew is different due to the nature of the process. The vast majority (AKA, not Boochcraft) contain less than 0.5% alcohol which allows it be marketed as non-alcoholic (for reference, a standard beer contains about 4.5% – nine times as much as kombucha).
So are bitters safe in recovery? Seriously – it’s all about your taste, personal preference, and protecting YOUR sobriety. Bitters are herbal, not sweet, and the alcohol could likely be detected by the most discerning of palates. For me, it doesn’t have much more effect on my taste buds than a fancy, bitter tonic water or an herbal non-alcoholic mixer, like Seedlip. If the warm, biting sting of alcohol (or even the thought of alcohol being in your drink) triggers your alcohol want-more-need-more receptors, then don’t drink bitters. Not to get all AA-woo woo on you guys, but as my sponsor said, “it’s between you and your higher power.” And so it is, whatever that may be.